Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Mike Baltrusitis
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Mike Baltrusitis

5720 S Bay Road
Cicero, NY 13039-8652

We are across the street from Drivers Village on South Bay Rd.

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


5720 S Bay Road
Cicero, NY 13039-8652


English, Polish

Currently, online auto quoting is not available. Please call, text, or visit us for an auto quote today. Ready for winter, dust off the skis, and put fresh gas in your snowmobiles. Be sure to call our team to put together a Personal Price Plan for your snowmobile and trailer needs.

We offer several discounts including Drive Safe and Save, call today for your current price.

Welcome to the Mike Baltrusitis State Farm Agency! We are happy to help families with insurance and financial services in Onondaga, Oswego, Oneida, Cayuga, Lewis, and Madison Counties. We are your local insurance agency in Cicero, and near Brewerton, Clay, Central Square, Baldwinsville, East Syracuse, Dewitt, Fayetteville, Manlius, Liverpool, Mattydale, Fulton and Bridgeport. We also service Blossvale, Camden, Hastings, Parish and Pulaski as well. We are also more than happy to provide a personalized auto insurance quote based upon your individual insurance coverage needs.

In 2016, Mike opened his State Farm agency to provide exceptional customer service and quality insurance to his community. Mike and his team have earned awards both company and industry wide by providing exceptional customer service and insurance including State Farm Ambassador Travel and State Farm Honor Club. We enjoy staying involved in our area by supporting local schools, The Make A Wish Foundation, the Keyes Music Foundation and other organizations such as Toys For Tots. We participate in nurse’s week, setting up our famous pumpkin patch, putting on ice cream socials and adopting local teachers to recognize their contribution to our youth as well as providing Fire Prevention Training material for students.

We also provide Business Auto Insurance and Commercial Auto Insurance. We also provide small business and business auto insurance as well auto insurance to our commercial customers.

As residents of the local area, we service Cicero, as well as the Greater Syracuse area and make relocation a simple and seamless process. Mike personally lives in Cicero so it should be comforting knowing that you are being protected by one of your neighbors. After all, like a good neighbor, Mike will be there! Click, call or come visit us at our office today.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Annuities

The Real Consequences of Drunk Driving

What's at stake if you're caught drunk driving? A lot. These tips help you avoid the dangers of drinking and driving.

Teen passenger safety

Talk to your young driver about passenger safety and learn some tips to help keep teen drivers and their passengers safe while in the car.

Tenant small business

As you get ready to rent space for your business, there are considerations to keep in mind.

View More Articles

Our friendly and dedicated team at Mike Baltrusitis Insurance is here to support and serve the communities of Cicero, Brewerton, Baldwinsville, Liverpool, and the entire state of New York. We are committed to helping our State Farm customers with all their insurance needs, whether it's auto, homeowner, life, boat, renters, financial, or any other type of coverage.

In addition to insurance, we can also assist with financing and refinancing through Rocket Pro. We take pride in being different in the Greater Syracuse area by providing exceptional customer service from our highly trained Insurance Professionals. We understand that everyone's insurance needs are unique, and we strive to offer quality coverage that meets your individual requirements.

Contact us today for a free insurance quote and discover your Personal Price Plan. We are here to be your partners in protecting what matters most to you and your community.

We have a fantastic team of Insurance Professionals that truly care about our customers. No matter what your need is, we will help inform you about your insurance options so you can make the proper choice for all of your insurance needs. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us so that we can put our insurance experience to work for you and create your personal price plan.


Margaret Baltrusitis

Office Manager

Hello There! My name is Margaret and I love working with the Mike Baltrusitis State Farm Insurance office here in Cicero, NY. I am the Office Manager and chances are I will be the first person you see when you walk into the office! Being that I really enjoy talking to everyone, I am happy to discuss your options for Life Insurance, Health Insurance, Auto Insurance and more. Originally from Queens, NY, I now live in Cicero NY and love spending time with my husband and two children.


Paige Dawson

Account Representative


Emily Oswald

Account Representative