Mike Baltrusitis

Welcome to the Mike Baltrusitis State Farm Insurance Agency in Cicero!

It’s always a good time to take a closer look at your insurance coverage and make sure everything lines up with your life today. Whether you’re preparing for the unexpected or simply want reassurance, our team is here to help with Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, and Life Insurance options that protect what matters most. From your vehicle and home to recreational items like ATVs or personal watercraft, we’ll walk you through your options and build a customized policy that fits your needs and budget—complete with valuable discounts like Drive Safe & Save, multi-car, multi-line, and accident prevention savings.

We’re proud to support individuals and families throughout Onondaga, Oswego, Oneida, Cayuga, Lewis, and Madison Counties, as well as communities like Brewerton, Clay, Central Square, Baldwinsville, East Syracuse, Dewitt, Fayetteville, Manlius, Liverpool, Mattydale, Fulton, and Bridgeport.

Conveniently located across the street from Drivers Village, our office also serves customers across New York, Connecticut, Vermont, and Pennsylvania, with virtual appointments available to make connecting even easier. We’re happy to assist in both English and Polish so you can feel confident and understood every step of the way.

Since opening our doors in 2016, and with over 10 years of experience with State Farm, I’ve been committed to helping people navigate their insurance needs and avoid the financial stress that can come from being underinsured. Our office has been recognized with honors like State Farm Ambassador Travel and State Farm Honor Club, reflecting our dedication to exceptional service and putting our customers’ interests first. I take pride in building real relationships—because being your local agent also means being your neighbor here in Cicero.

When I’m not in the office, you’ll likely find me restoring classic cars or experimenting with gourmet cooking at home with my wife, our two children, and our crew of three cats and one dog. Giving back is a big part of who we are. We proudly support local schools, fire departments, The Make-A-Wish Foundation, the Keyes Music Foundation, and programs like Toys for Tots. From hosting community events like pumpkin patches and ice cream socials to recognizing local teachers and sharing fire prevention resources, we stay actively involved in helping our community thrive.

In addition to personal coverage, we also offer Business Auto Insurance and Commercial Auto Insurance for small businesses and commercial customers. If you’re looking for professional, friendly guidance from a team that truly cares, we’re here to help—stop by our Cicero office, connect with us online, or reach out today to get started with a personalized quote.